Notable Antivaccinationists from History – Alfred Russel Wallace

Introduction

The media and elite would have you believe that everyone who is notable from history was a pro-vaccinationist. This is part of the strategy to portray antivaccinationists as inherently ‘cranks’ and that there has been no historical disagreement on vaccination. By considering notable antivaccinationists from history we are redressing the balance.

This article is about Alfred Russel Wallace (1823-1913), who is considered the co-founder of evolution by natural selection with Charles Darwin. He was also an antivaccinationist, spiritualist and political radical. It should go without saying that just because I discussed Wallace’s views in this article, it does not mean that I endorse every argument or action made by Wallace. This should be self evident but unfortunately it is not when people seek to strawman your arguments so I will state it upfront.

Scientific work

Wallace spent a lot of time in the Amazon and the Malaysian archipelago documenting the wildlife and collecting specimens. He observed differences between the wildlife of the two regions. Many of the specimens he uncovered were unknown to Europe. Many of the specimens he collected from the Amazon were lost due to a capsizing boat. He also discussed the theory of how new species came into existence.

In 1857, he exchanged letters with Darwin. He became one of the most passionate defenders of the theory of evolution by natural selection. However, he also maintained an interest in spiritualism, and did not consider consciousness to be explained by science.

Political Views

Alfred Russel Wallace believed that the ‘enclosures’ were a cause of injustice. Enclosure was a process that involved the removal of people from access to land. The term enclosure is primarily used in a UK context. This process involved laws removing common land, as well as debts and rent increases, leading to lack of access to land.

As such, Wallace advocated a policy of land nationalisation. He wrote an essay in 1880 called How to Nationalise the Land and was the first president of the Land Nationalisation Society founded in 1881. Restoration of access to land would redress social injustice.

Wallace also argued that the wealth of society had massively increased throughout the nineteenth century. The concept of rich and poor were normalised by the clergy and elite. He criticised the phenomenon of Social Darwinism defended by Huxley and Spencer.

Antivaccination Arguments

Wallace wrote an 1889 pamphlet called Vaccination Proved Useless and Dangerous from 45 years of Registration Statistics. In it, he put forward several arguments opposing vaccination, which will be summarised below.

Wallace argued that statistics showed a very small decline in smallpox deaths since vaccination had been made mandatory (in 1853). Furthermore, 1871 was the worst year for smallpox which was part of this period.

He argued that other diseases, such as typhoid, declined more over the same period but these diseases did not have a vaccine. This decline was due to sanitation, not vaccination.

He also pointed to the fact that vaccination does not mitigate smallpox if one contracts the disease. (Vaccinationists in the nineteenth century often argued even if vaccination does not always prevent smallpox, it can make it milder – an argument strongly revived during the Covid-19 ‘pandemic’). He stated that the % mortality before the vaccine was an average of 18.8% and after the vaccine was 18.5%, a negligible difference.

He also looked at the Army and Navy, where revaccination was common. Of course, outside of deaths in warfare, we would expect a lower death rate among Army and Navy men than the general population. They are selected on the grounds of youth and health, whereas the population at large contains infants (a more vulnerable group to smallpox) and sickly people. However, his statistics did not indicate a benefit of vaccination in this group.

He pointed to vaccination as the cause of other diseases, such as syphilis, cancer, and skin diseases. However, doctors do not record deaths from vaccination accurately, meaning that these deaths are underestimated.